I know someone who recovered memories of repeated abuse including from the age of four later in their teenage years. The parents could corroborate a lot of circumstances around those memories, which suggests that they’re likely broadly accurate. For instance, things like “they told their mother about the abuse when they were four, and the mother remembered that this conversation happened.” Or “the parents spoke to the abuser and he basically admitted it.” There was also suicidal ideation at around age six (similarity to Annie’s story). In addition, the person remembers things like, when playing with children’s toy figures (human-like animals), they would not play with these toy figures like ordinary children and instead think about plots that involve bleeding between legs and sexual assault. (This is much more detailed than Annie’s story, but remembering panic attacks as the first memory and having them as a child at least seems like evidence that she was strongly affected by something that had happened.)
Note that the person in question recovered these memories alone years before having any therapy.
It’s probably easier to remember abuse (or for this to manifest itself in child behavior in detailed ways, like with the toy figures) when it’s repeated. I think there’s a bunch of interpersonal variation also with respect to how people react to trauma. According to selfdecode (a service like 23andme), the person has alleles that make them unusually resilient to trauma, and yet they still struggled with cPTSD symptoms and the memories weren’t always accessible.
I know someone who recovered memories of repeated abuse including from the age of four later in their teenage years. The parents could corroborate a lot of circumstances around those memories, which suggests that they’re likely broadly accurate. For instance, things like “they told their mother about the abuse when they were four, and the mother remembered that this conversation happened.” Or “the parents spoke to the abuser and he basically admitted it.” There was also suicidal ideation at around age six (similarity to Annie’s story). In addition, the person remembers things like, when playing with children’s toy figures (human-like animals), they would not play with these toy figures like ordinary children and instead think about plots that involve bleeding between legs and sexual assault. (This is much more detailed than Annie’s story, but remembering panic attacks as the first memory and having them as a child at least seems like evidence that she was strongly affected by something that had happened.)
Note that the person in question recovered these memories alone years before having any therapy.
It’s probably easier to remember abuse (or for this to manifest itself in child behavior in detailed ways, like with the toy figures) when it’s repeated. I think there’s a bunch of interpersonal variation also with respect to how people react to trauma. According to selfdecode (a service like 23andme), the person has alleles that make them unusually resilient to trauma, and yet they still struggled with cPTSD symptoms and the memories weren’t always accessible.