Doing nothing might be preferable to intervening in that case. But I’m not sure if the advanced civilization in Bostrom’s scenario is intervening or merely opining. I would hope the latter.
If they’re merely opining, then why should we be appalled? Why would we even care? Let them opine to one another; it doesn’t affect us.
If they’re intervening (without our consent), then obviously this is a violation of our sovereignty and we should treat it as an act of war.
In any case, one “preserves” what one owns. These hypothetical advanced aliens are speaking as if they own us and our planet. This is obviously unacceptable as far as we’re concerned, and it would behoove us in this case to disabuse these aliens of such a notion at our earliest convenience.
Conversely, it makes perfect sense to speak of humans as collectively owning the natural resources of the Earth, including all the animals and so on. As such, wishing to preserve some aspects of it is entirely reasonable. (Whether we ultimately choose to do so is another question—but that it’s a question for us to answer, according to our preferences, is clear enough.)
Doing nothing might be preferable to intervening in that case. But I’m not sure if the advanced civilization in Bostrom’s scenario is intervening or merely opining. I would hope the latter.
If they’re merely opining, then why should we be appalled? Why would we even care? Let them opine to one another; it doesn’t affect us.
If they’re intervening (without our consent), then obviously this is a violation of our sovereignty and we should treat it as an act of war.
In any case, one “preserves” what one owns. These hypothetical advanced aliens are speaking as if they own us and our planet. This is obviously unacceptable as far as we’re concerned, and it would behoove us in this case to disabuse these aliens of such a notion at our earliest convenience.
Conversely, it makes perfect sense to speak of humans as collectively owning the natural resources of the Earth, including all the animals and so on. As such, wishing to preserve some aspects of it is entirely reasonable. (Whether we ultimately choose to do so is another question—but that it’s a question for us to answer, according to our preferences, is clear enough.)