I understand the “Vassar Crowd” to be a group of Michael Vassar’s friends who:
were highly critical of EA.
were critical of somewhat less so of the rationality community.
were partly at odds with the bulk of the rationality community in not being as hostile to EA as they thought they should have been.
Maybe you meet those qualifications, but as I understand it the “Vassar Crowd” started publishing blog posts on LessWrong and their own personal blogs, as well as on social media, over the course of a few months starting in the latter half of 2016. It was part of a semi-coordinated effort. While I wouldn’t posit a conspiracy, it seems like a lot of these criticisms of EA were developed in conversations within this group, and, given the name of the group, I assume different people were primarily nudged by Vassar. This also precipitated of Alyssa Vance’s Long-Term World Improvement mailing list.
It doesn’t seem to have continued as a crowd to the present, as the lives of the people involved have obviously changed a lot, and it doesn’t appear from the outside it is as cohesive anymore, I assume in large part because of Vassar’s decreased participation in the community. Ben seems to be one of the only people who is sustaining the effort to criticize EA as the others were before.
So while I appreciate the disclosure, I don’t know if in my previous comment was precise enough, as far as I understand it was that the Vassar Crowd was more a limited clique that was manifested much more in the past than present.
I understand the “Vassar Crowd” to be a group of Michael Vassar’s friends who:
were highly critical of EA.
were critical of somewhat less so of the rationality community.
were partly at odds with the bulk of the rationality community in not being as hostile to EA as they thought they should have been.
Maybe you meet those qualifications, but as I understand it the “Vassar Crowd” started publishing blog posts on LessWrong and their own personal blogs, as well as on social media, over the course of a few months starting in the latter half of 2016. It was part of a semi-coordinated effort. While I wouldn’t posit a conspiracy, it seems like a lot of these criticisms of EA were developed in conversations within this group, and, given the name of the group, I assume different people were primarily nudged by Vassar. This also precipitated of Alyssa Vance’s Long-Term World Improvement mailing list.
It doesn’t seem to have continued as a crowd to the present, as the lives of the people involved have obviously changed a lot, and it doesn’t appear from the outside it is as cohesive anymore, I assume in large part because of Vassar’s decreased participation in the community. Ben seems to be one of the only people who is sustaining the effort to criticize EA as the others were before.
So while I appreciate the disclosure, I don’t know if in my previous comment was precise enough, as far as I understand it was that the Vassar Crowd was more a limited clique that was manifested much more in the past than present.