For fiction that I re-read and find it not as good the second time, I suspect the newness of it was the driving force in my initial assessment. Permutation City was life-changing for me, but going back after having more transhumanism in my diet, I don’t know that it is even my favorite Greg Egan book.
There are other times where I have that feeling without even needing to re-read. “Upon reflection, I enjoyed that a lot at the time, but there is not a lot of there there.”
Frequently to both.
For fiction that I re-read and find it not as good the second time, I suspect the newness of it was the driving force in my initial assessment. Permutation City was life-changing for me, but going back after having more transhumanism in my diet, I don’t know that it is even my favorite Greg Egan book.
There are other times where I have that feeling without even needing to re-read. “Upon reflection, I enjoyed that a lot at the time, but there is not a lot of there there.”