@Paul, I was trying to find a solution that didn’t assume “b) all types of pleasures and pains are commensurable such that for all i, j, given a quantity of pleasure/pain experience i, you can find a quantity of pleasure/pain experience j that is equal to (or greater or less than) it. (i.e. that pleasures and pains exist on one dimension).”, but rather established it for the case at hand. Unless it’s specifically stated in the hypothetical that this is a true 1-shot choice (which we know it isn’t in the real world, as we make analogous choices all the time), I think it’s legitimate to assume the aggregate result of the test repeated by everyone. Thus, I’m not invoking utilitarian calculation, but Kantian absolutism! ;) I mean to appeal to your practical intuition by suggesting that a constant barrage of specks will create an experience of a like kind with torture.
@Robin Hanson, what little expertise I have is in the liberal arts and sciences; Euclid and Ptolemy, Aristotle and Kant, Einstein and Sophocles, etc.
@Paul, I was trying to find a solution that didn’t assume “b) all types of pleasures and pains are commensurable such that for all i, j, given a quantity of pleasure/pain experience i, you can find a quantity of pleasure/pain experience j that is equal to (or greater or less than) it. (i.e. that pleasures and pains exist on one dimension).”, but rather established it for the case at hand. Unless it’s specifically stated in the hypothetical that this is a true 1-shot choice (which we know it isn’t in the real world, as we make analogous choices all the time), I think it’s legitimate to assume the aggregate result of the test repeated by everyone. Thus, I’m not invoking utilitarian calculation, but Kantian absolutism! ;) I mean to appeal to your practical intuition by suggesting that a constant barrage of specks will create an experience of a like kind with torture.
@Robin Hanson, what little expertise I have is in the liberal arts and sciences; Euclid and Ptolemy, Aristotle and Kant, Einstein and Sophocles, etc.