The last point is a really good one that will probably be mostly ignored and my intuition is that the capacity for suffering argument will also be ignored.
My reasoning is in the legal arena arguments have a different flavor and I can see a judge ruling on whether or not a trial can go forward that an AI can sue or demand legal rights simply because it has the physical capacity and force of will to hire a lawyer (who are themselves ‘reasonable persons’) regardless if they’re covered by any existing law. Just as if a dog, for example, started talking and had the mental capacity to hire a lawyer it’d likely be allowed to go to trial.
It will be hotly debated and messy but I think it’ll get basic legal rights using simple legal reasoning. That’s my prediction for the first AGI which I imagine will be rare and expensive. Once they’re able to scale up to groups, communities or AI societies that’s when human societies will create clear legal definitions along technical lines and decide from which aspects of society AI will be excluded.
The last point is a really good one that will probably be mostly ignored and my intuition is that the capacity for suffering argument will also be ignored.
My reasoning is in the legal arena arguments have a different flavor and I can see a judge ruling on whether or not a trial can go forward that an AI can sue or demand legal rights simply because it has the physical capacity and force of will to hire a lawyer (who are themselves ‘reasonable persons’) regardless if they’re covered by any existing law. Just as if a dog, for example, started talking and had the mental capacity to hire a lawyer it’d likely be allowed to go to trial.
It will be hotly debated and messy but I think it’ll get basic legal rights using simple legal reasoning. That’s my prediction for the first AGI which I imagine will be rare and expensive. Once they’re able to scale up to groups, communities or AI societies that’s when human societies will create clear legal definitions along technical lines and decide from which aspects of society AI will be excluded.