Maybe. But would it change any of the conclusions?
It would change the regressions. I don’t know whether you think that’s an important part of the conclusion. It is certainly minor compared to the body of the work.
Again, if you think it does make a difference, I have provided all the code and data.
I think this is commendable; unfortunately I don’t know the language and while it seemed like it would take a few minutes to explain the insight, it seems like it would be a few hours for me to mug up enough to explore the change to the data.
[...] Disagree here as well.
Happy with that disagreement: I don’t have very strong support for my guess that a figure higher than $1 is best. I was just trying to explain how you might try to make the choice.
It would change the regressions. I don’t know whether you think that’s an important part of the conclusion. It is certainly minor compared to the body of the work.
I think this is commendable; unfortunately I don’t know the language and while it seemed like it would take a few minutes to explain the insight, it seems like it would be a few hours for me to mug up enough to explore the change to the data.
Happy with that disagreement: I don’t have very strong support for my guess that a figure higher than $1 is best. I was just trying to explain how you might try to make the choice.