Perhaps EY’s words were intemperate, but this feels more like taking the opportunity to have a jab at him than sitting down to address the broader problem he raises.
The point is valid that, probably for reasons of social training, more women than men are likely to be turned away by such snide criticism.
However, it’s not clear that that sort of tone is even remotely common in comments here, and in fact the negative score Eliezer’s comment received is strongly indicative that the community as a whole disapproved.
I hardly think −4 (now −3, apparently) is indicative of wholesale disapproval. Of course, if most people keep the default viewing threshold and don’t click through often then it’ would be impossible to tell. But since this very thread has a comment at −8, and I’ve seen several below −10, I don’t think that’s the case.
The point is valid that, probably for reasons of social training, more women than men are likely to be turned away by such snide criticism.
However, it’s not clear that that sort of tone is even remotely common in comments here, and in fact the negative score Eliezer’s comment received is strongly indicative that the community as a whole disapproved.
I hardly think −4 (now −3, apparently) is indicative of wholesale disapproval. Of course, if most people keep the default viewing threshold and don’t click through often then it’ would be impossible to tell. But since this very thread has a comment at −8, and I’ve seen several below −10, I don’t think that’s the case.