It may be worthwhile to cast a wider net in order to glean more professional opinions and sources of data while reducing any emotional response. Consider spending a useful amount of time exploring mailing lists, forums, and professional bodies. Google indicates there are tons of professional bodies in both the US and overseas that will have members who have dealt with similar experience and questions before. Some have membership requirements which a determined person can get around without too many problems, PM me if you get stuck. You may also consider asking a similar question on the various ‘Ask a question’ websites, but obviously the responses to a shotgun approach will vary wildly.
In doing so, you may be able to filter for more considered reactions if you phrase it as a hypothetical exam question or another form that encourages people to provide clear reasoning behind their answers. Focusing on the ‘undetermined’ section may lead to suggestions of non-obvious tests or papers that are obscure enough to have not appeared in initial searches.
Editing this page with useful summaries of more detailed information gleaned may boost its search ranking in the future. If it does, you may want to provide an easy way for someone to contact you without creating a LW account in case of the useful but lazy passerby.
If you have boldness, why not contact the writers of the textbook and ask them?
You may also consider asking a similar question on the various ‘Ask a question’ websites, but obviously the responses to a shotgun approach will vary wildly.
It may be worthwhile to cast a wider net in order to glean more professional opinions and sources of data while reducing any emotional response. Consider spending a useful amount of time exploring mailing lists, forums, and professional bodies. Google indicates there are tons of professional bodies in both the US and overseas that will have members who have dealt with similar experience and questions before. Some have membership requirements which a determined person can get around without too many problems, PM me if you get stuck. You may also consider asking a similar question on the various ‘Ask a question’ websites, but obviously the responses to a shotgun approach will vary wildly.
In doing so, you may be able to filter for more considered reactions if you phrase it as a hypothetical exam question or another form that encourages people to provide clear reasoning behind their answers. Focusing on the ‘undetermined’ section may lead to suggestions of non-obvious tests or papers that are obscure enough to have not appeared in initial searches.
Editing this page with useful summaries of more detailed information gleaned may boost its search ranking in the future. If it does, you may want to provide an easy way for someone to contact you without creating a LW account in case of the useful but lazy passerby.
If you have boldness, why not contact the writers of the textbook and ask them?
Thank you for this idea. I submitted a variant of my post to Health Stack Exchange.
I’ve edited my post to include contact information.
I will contact them tomorrow, but I don’t expect much from cold-emailing researchers.