You can have a theory that explains the behavior that occurs in the real world, or you can have a theory that admits Omohundro’s argument, but they are different theories and you can’t use both in the same argument.
Well yes. You give this list of things you claim are universal instrumental values, and it sounds like a plausible idea in our heads, but when we look at the real world, we find humans and other agents tend not in fact possess these, even as instrumental values.
Fancy giving your 2p on universal instrumental values and Goal System Zero...?
I contend that these are much the same idea wearing different outfits. Do you object to them too?
Well yes. You give this list of things you claim are universal instrumental values, and it sounds like a plausible idea in our heads, but when we look at the real world, we find humans and other agents tend not in fact possess these, even as instrumental values.
Hmm. Maybe I should give some examples—to make things more concrete.