It’s funny to a relatively small group of people. If you don’t know what dementors are, it’s not funny. If you do know what dementors are and haven’t read HPMOR, it’s probably not funny. Even if you have read HPMOR it’s not necessarily funny.
So… as I see it it fails to be funny for about 95% of people and is confusing for about 25% of people.
(Note I had to pay 5 Karma to post this)
It’s funny to a relatively small group of people. If you don’t know what dementors are, it’s not funny. If you do know what dementors are and haven’t read HPMOR, it’s probably not funny. Even if you have read HPMOR it’s not necessarily funny.
So… as I see it it fails to be funny for about 95% of people and is confusing for about 25% of people.