I have a guess, but I think that’s outside the purview of the purpose of these reviews.
I haven’t been deeply involved in the 2018 Review design process, maybe Ben and Ray have specific ideas, but my own vote is that reviewers should feel free to share whatever thoughts they have in response to their posts without worry about them going out of of bounds.
I could imagine it being better if non-author reviews try to stay focused, but I’d vote that authors feel quite free to share all their current thoughts.
I haven’t been deeply involved in the 2018 Review design process, maybe Ben and Ray have specific ideas, but my own vote is that reviewers should feel free to share whatever thoughts they have in response to their posts without worry about them going out of of bounds.
I could imagine it being better if non-author reviews try to stay focused, but I’d vote that authors feel quite free to share all their current thoughts.