it is still relatively unlikely that a person disagree for an opportunity to refine their model of the universe.
It still does happen though. I’ve only gotten this far in the Recommended Sequences, but I’ve been reading the comments whenever I finish a sub-sequence; and they (a) definitely add to the understanding, and (b) expose occasional comment threads where two people arrive at mutual understanding (clear up lexical miscommunication etc.). “oops” moments are rare, but the whole karma system seems great for occasional productive discourse.
That is obviously not an analog for the face-to-face experience, but isn’t the “take a chance on it” approach still better then a general prohibitive “not worth it” attitude? You can be polite (self-skeptical etc.) while probing your metaphorical opponent. Non confrontational discussions are kind of essential to furthering one’s understanding about what’s going on and why.
It still does happen though. I’ve only gotten this far in the Recommended Sequences, but I’ve been reading the comments whenever I finish a sub-sequence; and they (a) definitely add to the understanding, and (b) expose occasional comment threads where two people arrive at mutual understanding (clear up lexical miscommunication etc.). “oops” moments are rare, but the whole karma system seems great for occasional productive discourse.
That is obviously not an analog for the face-to-face experience, but isn’t the “take a chance on it” approach still better then a general prohibitive “not worth it” attitude? You can be polite (self-skeptical etc.) while probing your metaphorical opponent. Non confrontational discussions are kind of essential to furthering one’s understanding about what’s going on and why.