I think that the only rational reason to treat your own experience as more significant, given the constraints of the problem, is the anthropic nature of the evidence. And that explains nicely why others shouldn’t update as much.
If you think there’s an example that isolates non-anthropic effects that behave similarly, perhaps. I’ll reserve judgement until I see such an example—for now, I don’t know of any.
I think that the only rational reason to treat your own experience as more significant, given the constraints of the problem, is the anthropic nature of the evidence. And that explains nicely why others shouldn’t update as much.
If you think there’s an example that isolates non-anthropic effects that behave similarly, perhaps. I’ll reserve judgement until I see such an example—for now, I don’t know of any.