Requiring me to think up the example before telling me the exact nature of your morality is unfair.
I don’t have to have an exact morality to be sceptical of the idea that consequentialism is the One True Theory.
This reply does not fit the context. If Will is asked to instantiate from a general principle to a specific example then it is not reasonable to declare the general principle null because the specific example does not apply to the morality you happen to be thinking of.
(And the “One True Theory” business a far less subtle straw man.)
This reply does not fit the context. If Will is asked to instantiate from a general principle to a specific example then it is not reasonable to declare the general principle null because the specific example does not apply to the morality you happen to be thinking of.
(And the “One True Theory” business a far less subtle straw man.)