Suppose Holden Karnofsky had written the exact post above (“Natural selection defeats the orthogonality thesis”) and some unknown had written the substantive points from Holden’s critique (minus the GiveWell-specific stuff). What karma values would you expect for those two posts?
Suppose Holden Karnofsky had written the exact post above (“Natural selection defeats the orthogonality thesis”) and some unknown had written the substantive points from Holden’s critique (minus the GiveWell-specific stuff). What karma values would you expect for those two posts?