what observation can distinguish those which actually are loving?
I think, evidence that the universe was designed with some degree of attention to our well-being. If the universe is unexpectedly kind to us, or if we are especially well taken care of, would be evidence of a loving God.
I’m conflicted about which universe we’re in. Things could certainly be worse, but it’s also not very good.
Is life more tolerable to us than we’d expect by random chance?
But for sure, just look at outcome. It only muddles to consider intention for three reasons:
(1) it is the outcome that we’re concerned with, “pretending” versus “sincere” has no meaning if there’s no distinguishing effect on observation
(2) asking about pretending is really asking about whether the evidence could be ‘tricking’ us; it is always a possibility that the evidence leads us to the wrong conclusion with some probability, or that induction over time doesn’t apply
(2) even if the creator is non-sentient, we can still ask if the universe is ‘us-loving’ or not
I think, evidence that the universe was designed with some degree of attention to our well-being. If the universe is unexpectedly kind to us, or if we are especially well taken care of, would be evidence of a loving God.
I’m conflicted about which universe we’re in. Things could certainly be worse, but it’s also not very good. Is life more tolerable to us than we’d expect by random chance?
But for sure, just look at outcome. It only muddles to consider intention for three reasons:
(1) it is the outcome that we’re concerned with, “pretending” versus “sincere” has no meaning if there’s no distinguishing effect on observation
(2) asking about pretending is really asking about whether the evidence could be ‘tricking’ us; it is always a possibility that the evidence leads us to the wrong conclusion with some probability, or that induction over time doesn’t apply
(2) even if the creator is non-sentient, we can still ask if the universe is ‘us-loving’ or not