I dunno. I’d be pretty happy with a system that produced reasonable output when staffed with idiots, because that seems like a certainty. I actually think that’s probably why democracy seems to be better than monarchies—it has a much lower requirement for smarts/benevolence. “Without suffering” may be a high bar, but the universe is allowed to give us problems like that! (And I don’t think that democracy is even close to a complete solution.)
EDIT: Also, perhaps the entirety of the system should be to make sure that an “utter genius with leet rationality skillz” is in the top position? I’d be very happy with a system that caused that even when staffed by morons.
Seems to me that a system that incentivized putting smart people in high places would do better in the long run than one that was designed to be robust against idiocy and didn’t concern itself with those incentives.
The trick is making sure those incentives don’t end up Goodharting themselves. Don’t think I’ve ever heard of a system that’s completely solved that problem yet.
I dunno. I’d be pretty happy with a system that produced reasonable output when staffed with idiots, because that seems like a certainty. I actually think that’s probably why democracy seems to be better than monarchies—it has a much lower requirement for smarts/benevolence. “Without suffering” may be a high bar, but the universe is allowed to give us problems like that! (And I don’t think that democracy is even close to a complete solution.)
EDIT: Also, perhaps the entirety of the system should be to make sure that an “utter genius with leet rationality skillz” is in the top position? I’d be very happy with a system that caused that even when staffed by morons.
Seems to me that a system that incentivized putting smart people in high places would do better in the long run than one that was designed to be robust against idiocy and didn’t concern itself with those incentives.
The trick is making sure those incentives don’t end up Goodharting themselves. Don’t think I’ve ever heard of a system that’s completely solved that problem yet.