I think a major determinant of the choice here depends on whether or not the “chooser” knows about the previous results. If you know that in the previous scenarios, people who choose only one box win, then by all means, choosing only one box is the rational decision.
If you don’t have this prior information, then choosing both boxes seems more rational.
I think a major determinant of the choice here depends on whether or not the “chooser” knows about the previous results. If you know that in the previous scenarios, people who choose only one box win, then by all means, choosing only one box is the rational decision.
If you don’t have this prior information, then choosing both boxes seems more rational.