Thanks for the post, it’s a great idea to have both arguments.
My personal preference would be to have both arguments to be the same length to properly compare the strength of the arguments (skeptic is one paragraph, advocate is 3-6x longer), and not always in the same order skeptic then advocate, but also advocate → skeptic or even skeptic → advocate --> skeptic → …, so it does not appear like one is the “haven’t thought about it much” view.
Thanks for the post, it’s a great idea to have both arguments.
My personal preference would be to have both arguments to be the same length to properly compare the strength of the arguments (skeptic is one paragraph, advocate is 3-6x longer), and not always in the same order skeptic then advocate, but also advocate → skeptic or even skeptic → advocate --> skeptic → …, so it does not appear like one is the “haven’t thought about it much” view.