Bob’s reply is not concerned with the truth of whether X did Y in the Bayesian sense. Bob doesn’t argue about what the correct probability happens to be.
It’s concerned with dispute resolution. In a discussion about truth, wanting doesn’t matter. In a process of dispute resolution it matters a great deal.
Bob’s reply is not concerned with the truth of whether X did Y in the Bayesian sense. Bob doesn’t argue about what the correct probability happens to be.
It’s concerned with dispute resolution. In a discussion about truth, wanting doesn’t matter. In a process of dispute resolution it matters a great deal.