This is a cool formulation. It’s interesting that there are other things that can happen to you not similar to “being persuaded of a metaethical theory” that entail that whenever you are told to do X you’re compelled to do X. (Voodoo or whatever.)
I could get into how much I hate this kind of rejoinder if you bait me some more. I wasn’t asking you for the number of acres in a square mile. Let me just rephrase:
I hadn’t heard of motivational internalism before, could you expand your comment?
I thought being persuaded of a metaethical theory entails that whenever the theory tells you you should do X, you would feel compelled to do X.
This is a cool formulation. It’s interesting that there are other things that can happen to you not similar to “being persuaded of a metaethical theory” that entail that whenever you are told to do X you’re compelled to do X. (Voodoo or whatever.)
Only if motivational internalism is true. But motivational internalism is false.
What’s that?
Here, let me Google that for you.
I could get into how much I hate this kind of rejoinder if you bait me some more. I wasn’t asking you for the number of acres in a square mile. Let me just rephrase:
I hadn’t heard of motivational internalism before, could you expand your comment?